A single mugshot can become a lasting stain on someone’s online reputation. Whether the charges were dropped, dismissed, or decades old, that image often lingers at the top of search results—impacting job offers, relationships, and peace of mind.
In an effort to get mugshots off Google, people often move too quickly, trust the wrong services, or misunderstand the rules. The process isn’t easy—but it’s not impossible either. Avoiding these common mistakes can save time, money, and unnecessary frustration.
There’s so much more to discover—browse our related posts!
Why Mugshots Stick—and Why People Want Them Gone
Mugshots are public records. Once they’re published by law enforcement or scraped by third-party websites, they often end up indexed in Google search results. This makes them highly visible—sometimes years after the arrest has occurred.
And the consequences are real—employers, landlords, and even dating partners frequently Google names. A visible mugshot, even for an old or dismissed charge, can lead to unfair assumptions and missed opportunities.
That’s why many people turn to firms like NetReputation or RemoveMugshots for help navigating the removal process.
Mistake #1: Ignoring Legal Options
Many people jump straight to online solutions or private companies without exploring whether they have legal rights to removal.
Depending on your state, there may be laws requiring mugshot websites to remove images under certain conditions—such as dropped charges, expungements, or mistaken identity. Some individuals can even petition courts to order removals or issue takedown notices directly.
In cases where charges were dismissed or never filed, a formal legal letter can sometimes be more effective than any online strategy. Working with a local attorney or contacting legal aid is often the first step people overlook.
Mistake #2: Using the Wrong Removal Services
Not all reputation services are equal. Some make vague promises, overcharge, or fail to deliver on their commitments. The worst simply resurface the same mugshots on other sites after “removal.”
A trustworthy firm should:
- Be transparent about pricing
- Offer clear timelines and removal scopes
- Provide proof of past results
Firms like InternetReputation, EraseMugshots, or ReputationSciences have built credibility in this space—but it’s still important to do your homework. Look for verified reviews, case studies, and clear contracts before committing.
Mistake #3: Misunderstanding Google’s Role
Google doesn’t host mugshots. It indexes them from external websites. That means getting a mugshot removed from Google usually means removing it from the source site first.
What Google Can Do:
- Remove outdated or legally sensitive content (with documentation)
- De-index pages after legal requests are submitted
What Google Won’t Do:
- Remove content just because it’s embarrassing
- Get involved in disputes between users and third-party sites
People often assume submitting a simple request will make the content vanish. In reality, Google typically requires legal evidence, such as court orders or privacy claims, before taking action.
Mistake #4: Filing Incomplete or Incorrect Requests
If you do have grounds to request a takedown from Google or a hosting site, accuracy is key. Submitting incomplete or inconsistent information—such as missing URLs, no explanation of harm, or a lack of legal documents—often results in automatic denials.
Always include:
- A clear explanation of the issue
- Documentation showing dismissal, expungement, or harm
- Direct URLs of the offending content
Be prepared to follow up. Many requests require multiple rounds of communication or appeals.
Mistake #5: Assuming Every Mugshot Is Removable
Not all mugshots can be legally removed from public records. If the arrest led to a conviction, or if the site is hosted in a jurisdiction with weak privacy laws, there may be little legal leverage.
In these cases, removal is still possible—but more difficult. That’s why setting realistic expectations is important.
Rather than obsessing over a single image, some individuals benefit more from working with firms like OnlineReputation or InternetPrivacy to build positive search results that push the mugshot lower in rankings.
Mistake #6: Overlooking Alternatives to Removal
Even if you can’t get a mugshot off Google, you’re not out of options. Reputation can be reshaped through strategy and persistence.
Some alternatives include:
- Creating strong LinkedIn and professional profiles that appear above negative content
- Publishing positive content, like articles, press mentions, or blog posts under your name
- Asking for reviews or testimonials to appear on sites that rank highly in search
- Maintaining an active, visible social media presence that reflects your values and accomplishments
The goal isn’t to erase history—it’s to put it in context.
A Smarter Strategy for Getting Mugshots Off Google
Here’s a simplified roadmap that works better than rushing into the wrong tactics:
- Identify the Hosting Site
Is the image on a mugshot aggregator, a local news site, or a law enforcement page? - Check Legal Eligibility
Were the charges dropped? Expunged? Is your state among those with mugshot removal laws? - Try Direct Contact First
Some sites will remove mugshots upon request, especially with proof of a legal dismissal. - Submit a Legal Request to Google
If you have documentation, submit a formal takedown request with all required details. - Consider Professional Help
If you’re getting nowhere, look for established firms with a clear, verifiable track record. - Build a Strong Online Identity
Offset the negative result by populating search results with positive, accurate information.
Final Thoughts
Trying to remove mugshots from Google can be frustrating—but it doesn’t have to be fruitless. The key is understanding what Google can do, knowing your legal options, and choosing the right strategy instead of reacting impulsively.
Avoiding these common mistakes can save you time, money, and unnecessary stress. Whether you handle it on your own or with the help of experts like NetReputation or RemoveMugshots, the goal remains the same: to regain control of your online identity—and your future.
Don’t miss out on more great reads—click through our featured posts!
