If you are expecting a baby and comparing childcare options early, you may come across the terms’ childminder’ and ‘nanny’. In Singapore, you may also come across confinement nanny Singapore services for the postpartum month, which adds another layer to your decision.
This guide explains childminder vs nanny in practical terms, then shows how a confinement nanny fits in when your priority is recovery, feeding support, and newborn routines at home.
What is a Childminder?
A childminder cares for children in the childminder’s own home. In the UK, childminders typically follow the Early Years Foundation Stage (EYFS), a government framework that guides learning, development, and care for children from birth to age five.
Childminders often care for a small group of children at a time, which can suit families who want a home-like environment with peer social interaction.
What is A Nanny?
A nanny works in your home, focusing on your child’s routine, care, and development within your household setup. Many families choose a nanny when they want more personalised schedules, fewer transitions for the child, and support that fits around home life.
Because the nanny works in your space, you typically get more flexibility with timing, routines, and the way care integrates into family life.
You may also enjoy this insight that connects perfectly with what you read.
Childminder vs Nanny: The Key Differences at a Glance
Here is a straightforward comparison to help you shortlist quickly.
| Factor | Childminder | Nanny |
| Where care happens | Childminder’s home | Your home |
| Care style | Small group care | 1-to-1 personalised care (or siblings together) |
| Routine control | Childminder’s daily structure | Built around your baby’s and family’s routines |
| Social interaction | Natural peer group | Needs planned playdates and outings |
| Best fit for | Older babies and toddlers who enjoy group settings | Newborns, siblings, or families who need tailored routines |
For expecting parents, the most significant practical difference is location. In the early postpartum weeks, many families prefer at-home care because travel, feeding, and recovery already require a considerable amount of energy.
A Note on Regulation and Checks (Why This Matters to Parents)
Regulation varies by country, but understanding the concept is helpful. In England, childminders who care for children under 8 for more than 2 hours a day must register with Ofsted (the Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills). This typically includes requirements such as background checks, paediatric first aid training, safeguarding training, and insurance.
Nannies in the UK do not always require mandatory Ofsted registration, so families often assess qualifications and experience more directly.
For Singapore-based parents, the key takeaway is to ask clearly about training, scope of work, and accountability, especially if you are arranging newborn care while recovering.
Cost Expectations: What Research Shows (UK Context)
Cost often drives the first shortlist. UK research shows that full-time childminder care averages approximately £202 per week for children under two, while live-in nanny costs often range from £400 to £650 per week for around 50 hours.
These figures reflect typical UK market pricing and highlight the usual trade-off: group care costs less, while 1-to-1 home care costs more.
Disclaimer: The figures above are general UK estimates that may vary depending on location, schedule, duties, and market conditions. They do not represent fees in Singapore.
From Childcare to Postpartum Care: Where a Confinement Nanny Fits
A standard nanny role focuses on childcare within your family routine. A confinement nanny role focuses on postpartum support alongside newborn care.
In Singapore, families often use the term “confinement nanny” or “confinement lady” to describe a trained caregiver who supports mums during the postpartum period with practical, day-to-day help centred on recovery and newborn routines.
If your main concerns include feeding in the middle of the night, settling a newborn, and maintaining postpartum meals, you likely need a confinement-focused role rather than a general childcare setup.
You can read more about PEM’s approach to a confinement lady Singapore service by clicking here when you want structured postpartum support at home.
What to Choose Based on Your Stage of Pregnancy and Postpartum Plan
Different options make sense at different times. Use these common scenarios to guide your decision.
If you are in 1st trimester (planning and budgeting)
A childminder may become relevant later, after you return to work and your baby is older.
A confinement nanny becomes relevant if you want support during the first month or longer, especially if you expect limited family help or you want guided routines from day one.
If you are in the 2nd trimester (locking in practical arrangements)
Now is a good time to map out:
- Who supports you right after birth
- Your feeding preference (breastfeeding, mixed, or formula)
- How much hands-on help do you want at night
If you expect a C-section or you worry about sleep deprivation, prioritise at-home support that includes day and night baby care, so you can rest while someone experienced handles routine baby tasks.
If you are in the 3rd trimester (finalising routines and home setup)
Focus on operational details:
- Where the baby sleeps and how you want night routines to run
- How meals and laundry will be managed when you are recovering
- What level of breastfeeding guidance do you want at home
A confinement nanny can keep your home running in a postpartum-appropriate way while you concentrate on healing and bonding.
What PEM Nannies Do During Confinement (Clear Job Scope)
PEM nannies support mums with a defined confinement scope that prioritises newborn care and maternal recovery needs. Your nanny focuses on:
- Day and night baby care, including feeding support, diapering, soothing, and routine building
- Confinement food and tonic cooking, aligned with your preferences and household needs
- Herbal bath preparation (herbal bath refers to a warm bath prepared with specific herbs traditionally used during confinement for comfort and self-care)
- Breastfeeding guidance, such as positioning support and practical routine tips (PEM nannies do not provide medical advice)
- Laundry related to mum and baby, keeping essentials clean and ready
When considering confinement nanny Singapore options, ask whether the caregiver can consistently handle the full scope. The early weeks often feel repetitive and demanding, so reliable routines matter more than occasional help.
Why Families Choose PEM for Postpartum Care in Singapore
When you feel tired, sore, and emotionally stretched, you need calm, experienced support you can trust in your home.
PEM brings structure and reliability to that period:
- PEM nannies complete 150 hours of training based on modules reviewed by a leading mum and baby expert.
- PEM has over 30 years of industry experience, with more than 550 nannies who have served over 50,000 mothers.
- PEM guarantees the nanny’s arrival so that you can plan your postpartum support with more confidence.
- PEM nannies work within a clear confinement scope that supports both mum and baby.
If you want an add-on to your routine, PEM nannies are trained to prepare herbal packages, and mothers can add this package at a special rate.
Quick Decision Checklist: Which Option Matches Your Needs?
Choose a childminder if you want:
- Group social time for an older baby or toddler
- Care that happens outside your home
- A typically lower-cost childcare route compared with a nanny
Choose a nanny if you want:
- Care in your home with routines you set
- 1-to-1 personalised care for your child
- More flexibility for family schedules
Choose a confinement nanny if you want:
- Postpartum-focused support for mum plus newborn routines
- Confinement food, tonic cooking, and herbal bath preparation as part of the plan
- Day and night baby care that protects your rest and recovery
The correct answer depends on your baby’s age, your recovery expectations, and how much at-home structure you want during the postpartum period.If you want calm, experienced confinement support you can count on, enquire now.
Explore more stories, tips, and ideas waiting for you at Management Works Media.
